The self-sufficient workstation operating system
How do you decide what operating system to install on your new self-sufficient workstation? There are three very viable alternatives. Windows 11, Linux or Macintosh. As I don’t have Macintosh hardware or much expertise in particular, I will have to leave that to somebody else as a recommendation. For this article we’re going to focus on Windows or Linux.
When setting up your self-sufficient computer, the operating system is usually where the discussion gets very, let’s say passionate, which is great. This is particularly true when one of the operating systems is Linux. There are many different flavors of Linux and they’re all very capable but often have a different emphasis or focus.
I’m going to focus on making a computer self-sufficient so that you don’t need the internet, easy to use, and runs the software that you need. I’m going to pick Windows 11 and Linux Mint as my two alternatives. As I said before, there are many capable alternatives but one of the goals of “apocalyptic computing” is to be practical and simple. If you don’t have strong biases here are two effective and simple choices that will serve you well.
The choice of which may come down to familiarity, but also what hardware you want to run on and licensing considerations.
Windows is proprietary and you need to have a legally licensed version to install it. Additionally, it is very familiar to most computer users, as most home computers come with it preinstalled and it’s probably what you use at work. However, you usually need pretty robust modern hardware and it can be sensitive to some of those things.
Linux, on the other hand, is in the open-source world, which makes its licensing considerations much less onerous, and usually affordable. Next minute is free to download and install for your personal use as you see fit. It also tends to run on older repurposed hardware better than a Windows environment.
The first two considerations are: what do you have for hardware? And what are you comfortable with?
Windows 11
Windows 11 is the natural choice when compatibility with commercial software and Windows-specific hardware is important. If an official version of Microsoft Office is an absolute requirement, then Windows 11 is your easier choice. If you purchase a new computer, it often comes with a Windows 11 license preinstalled so that takes care of any licensing issues you may have. If you’re building a self-sufficient workstation from scratch and you want to use Windows 11, you will need to purchase a license.
The disadvantage is that Windows 11 is increasingly designed around an Internet-connected environment. Microsoft strongly encourages use of a Microsoft account, cloud services, OneDrive, online activation, and automatic updates. Windows 11 also has relatively demanding hardware requirements, including TPM 2.0, Secure Boot, and supported processors. In other words you need very recent, modern, and robust hardware to run Windows 11.
Windows 11 can still be used on an offline computer, but preparation is important. Before disconnecting the machine, create Windows 11 installation media on another computer and download any required hardware drivers. It is particularly useful to have chipset, video, storage, Ethernet, and Wi-Fi drivers available on a USB drive.
Linux Mint
Linux Mint is a good choice for a computer intended to operate primarily or completely offline. It is free, open source, relatively lightweight, and does not require an online account or Internet-based activation. Mint also works well on older computers that may not meet Microsoft’s Windows 11 hardware requirements. Its Cinnamon desktop provides a traditional desktop interface that should be familiar to Windows users. If you have a 3- or 4-year-old machine that still has a little life in it, Linux Mint would be an excellent choice.
The disadvantage is that it won’t run all of your Windows’s software natively. For your self-sufficient workstation we need to find alternative software options. Things such as LibreOffice instead of Microsoft Office. Perhaps GNU Cash instead of QuickBooks or gimp instead of photoshop. The good news is there is a vast and deep library of Linux alternatives for any software you can possibly imagine.
Here is a table of computer uses that might help your decision.
| Requirement | Windows 11 | Linux Mint |
| General desktop use | Excellent | Excellent |
| Web browser / local HTML | Excellent | Excellent |
| LibreOffice | Excellent | Excellent |
| Microsoft Office desktop | Best choice | Limited |
| PDF reading | Excellent | Excellent |
| Photos / video / music | Excellent | Excellent |
| Programming | Excellent | Excellent |
| PostgreSQL / databases | Excellent | Excellent |
| Local web server | Excellent | Excellent |
| Windows-only programs | Excellent | Problematic |
| Older hardware | Fair–Good | Excellent |
| No online account | Possible, but less convenient | Natural fit |
| No Internet activation | Depends on software | Excellent |
| Installing software offline | Good with preparation | Good with preparation |
| Long-term offline independence | Good | Very good |
There is another discussion where you don’t have to choose between Windows and Linux and that’s called a dual-boot installation. That’s a little more complicated and we’ll discuss that in another article. If you’re just getting started and you want to begin building a machine, pick one of these two alternatives and move forward.
Your decision could be as simple as these two questions:
- Do I have essential Windows-only applications for which there is no open source alternative ? If yes, keep Windows available.
- Do I want the machine to function indefinitely without accounts, activation, subscriptions, or cloud dependencies? That strongly favors Linux Mint.
For some people the most difficult decision is knowing there isn’t one right answer. You simply have to choose.
Once you have made a decision there are three videos to make this easy
The first one to watch on Apocalyptic Computing is how to download Rufus. That will help you create a bootable USB drive so you’ll need a thumb drive at least 16 GB in size that you can erase.
From there you can watch the resource video on how to install Windows 11 or alternatively watch the resource video on how to install Linux Mint.
Good luck!
